“AI”, agents, LLMs, bots

This forum is under assault.

In the past, we’ve had to sporadically deal with spammers creating accounts, sometimes using automation scripts, and posting their bullshit. The automation script-based ones were super annoying and forced me to sit there and manually delete dozens of accounts and also temporarily suspend the public creation of new accounts to stop them just generating a bunch more. However, these episodes were sparse and did not really challenge the overall resilience of this forum. Moreover, the Discourse forum software has been constantly improved, making it harder and harder to abuse in this old way.

Here in Fall 2026, we are seeing something new: fake people creating accounts and posting pseudo-helpful posts, created/enabled using LLMs. The behavior of these agents is much harder for the forum software to automatically detect and neutralize for various reasons that can be summarized as “they act more like people”. They’re still primitive enough that they intuitively stand out as “a bit off” once they start posting, but it’s not always immediately apparent.

Why are bots infiltrating this relatively obscure forum on spirits and cocktails? The only explanation I can think of—so far—is that any Discourse-based forum has been identified by some malicious people as a useful place to R&D more effective “fake people” for later commercial/criminal purposes. (Many other forums are facing the same challenge.) The perpetrators are perfectly happy to compromise and damage this forum or anything else that serves their purpose. They did not ask permission. They don’t care about you or me, and they certainly do not care about what we have been discussing here.

This is an arms race and we are collateral damage. We are an externality (i.e., roadkill). And we are a single drop in a veritable ocean of externalities.

We may have choices about how overall to respond to this assault, but they all come with costs, both short-term and long-term. For the moment, I have shut off the creation of new accounts to protect us, and that comes with a cost. If I can’t turn it back on, then new users will have to contact me and request access to the forum. The cost is the death of “free anonymous access” to this forum. The higher barrier means fewer future participants as well as more hassle for me. So, yes, this threat is of an existential nature.

This may not be the busiest forum around, but I am quite proud of its signal-to-noise ratio and that many serious people find it a safe space to invest their time in. I will try to keep you posted as the situation evolves.

12 Likes