Cognac, etc

I have taken to heart @Splificator ’s advice in Imbibe that pre-prohibition cocktails should be made with one of the few >40% ABV VSOP cognacs such as Ferrand 1840 or Royer Force. But damned if there aren’t a ton of those brandy cocktails, and a ton of other cognacs out there.

  1. Have any other cognacs turned up that are on the stronger side? Pretty depressing that the cognacs that dominate the US market are 40%, even the so-called premium expressions.
  2. Are there higher-strength non-cognac brandies that can compete in quality? (I’m pretty pleased with www.berensoldfashionedbrandy.com at 45%.)
  3. When did ABV’s start to shrink, such that a “contemporary” bottling would be more “accurate” in a recipe? 1950’s? 30’s?
  4. What else is there to know about cognac? Are there any sub groupings, or shared characteristics besides VS, VSOP, XO? Are the crus (grande champagne, petite champagne, borderies) indicative of meaningful things in the glass, or just a prestige markup?
5 Likes

…a Sidecar made with a brandy that matches the style of a 19th-century brandy yields the best results. Today, such a brandy is most comparable to a classic Armagnac, and as the one used by Frank Meier had presumably spent a long time in the cask and consequently developed intense notes of wood and rancio, we chose a twenty-five-year-old Armagnac.

From the recent Lemons – Part 1: Introduction – Bar-Vademecum

Can you elaborate on this, @armin ?

I presume Armin will be expanding on his take on the brandy situation in part two of his Sidecar post.

Alas, I don’t have much to add on this topic. I think Louis Royer Force 53 has been gone from the market for some years. Some higher proof cognacs are discussed here, but they all seem exotic and spendy.

There will be a new post on the Sidecar. The second part, which focuses on Old World lemons, has just been published: Lemons – Part 2: The Old World – Bar-Vademecum
Next up is the New World, as lemons were different there. Then there’ll be a post applying the insights gained to the Sidecar, followed by one for the Sour.

But I can try to outline the findings briefly: Lemons have a ‘terroir’. Ideally, for the Sidecar, you need lemons from the northern Mediterranean coast. Ligurian lemons work very well. They were/are sweeter and more aromatic. Sicilian lemons (and those favoured in the US, or today’s supermarket lemons) were/are rather sour and bitter by comparison. For the Sidecar, one should also use an Armagnac, preferably a 25-year-old one. A modern cognac tends to add bitterness.

And an important realisation: lemons were smaller back then; on average, we can assume 24 g of lemon juice per lemon. This casts the 19th-century sours in a completely different light. If we translate Harry Johnson’s recipe, it reads:

Mix 12.5 ml of lemon juice, 10 g of icing sugar and 25 ml of soda water together until the sugar has dissolved. Soda water is important because the sodium bicarbonate it contains reacts with the citric acid. Plain water won’t work; it must be proper soda water containing sodium bicarbonate. Add 60 ml of bourbon and ice cubes, then stir until chilled.

The difference is enormous compared to today’s sours, and I find the historical version much better.

2 Likes